Fisherman sandals are slated to be the it-shoe of the summer — here are 20 pairs that have our style editors hooked

I've always had a bit of a love-hate relationship with sandals. While I can't deny their stylish appeal, many of the pairs I've owned lack comfort and cannot compare to even mildly supportive sneakers. That's why I was intrigued by Bared Footwear's sandals crafted with a biomechanical footbed, which the brand claims offers unparalleled comfort. After wearing these leather fisherman sandals for a hectic day of running errands, I can agree: They're the most comfortable sandals I've ever worn. Exceptional details include soft, cushy leather and a roomy square toe area, despite the shoe's elongated, pointed-toe look. The sandals' slightly elevated heels felt more supportive and less taxing than a fully flat shoe.

It's a tricky balance for a shoe to strike between wearability and aesthetics, but these versatile fisherman sandals nailed it. The thin leather straps, gold hardware, and sleek pointed toe added up to an elevated sandal that paired perfectly with a floral summer dress. Still, they were easily dressed down with stretchy pants and a casual tee. They're true to size and also come in a metallic gold colorway, which I'm seriously considering purchasing as a dance-floor-friendly alternative for a wedding guest sandal.

Learn about another pair of Bared Footwear sandals that we loved in our guide to the best walking sandals for women.

Everlane's improved staples rarely risk discomfort in the name of aesthetics, though these fisherman sandals excel in both areas. Crafted from soft leather with a padded insole, the square-toe buckle sandals come in four neutral hues. The leather is sourced from a tannery rated Gold by the Leather Working Group. We suggest styling these with jeans and a casual tee or a flowy sundress.

For a sophisticated take on the fisherman sandal, look no further than this wide-strap version with an elongated square toe from Vagabond. Available in off-white and black Nappa LWG-rated leather, the cage sandals are less than half an inch high, making them ideal for evening occasions when both beauty and comfort are equally important. The brand recommends applying a neutral shoe cream to extend the leather's lifespan.

Elevated literally and figuratively, this T-strap caged sandal includes a braided jute sole with a two-inch platform. The insole is cushioned with foam and lined with natural cowhide leather for better breathability. It pairs beautifully with a summer dress, but can also be worn to zhuzh up a casual ensemble. Choose from seven colors ranging from a neutral camel to a bold fuchsia.

Designed for comfort but not lacking in style, this contemporary fisherman sandal features a cushioned two-inch footbed and a full-grain leather upper. The rubber lug sole has all the grip you'd expect from a pair of Sorel performance shoes. It'll come in handy during summer adventures when navigating uneven terrain like rocky shorelines. Meanwhile, the croc embossed, thick, adjustable straps come in four hues including a vibrant, sunny yellow.

See another pair of Sorel sandals we tested in our guide to the best walking sandals for women.

The "Milano" is a dainty sandal made for travel. Its flat, padded sole is comfy for walking even on European cobblestone streets, and its LGW-certified leather straps are delicate and stylish. The versatile cage-toe shoe pairs well with both casual and dressier outfits, making it a versatile addition to a summer travel capsule wardrobe.

This chunky dad sandal is a far cry from the ugly shoe it references. With a latticework of pebbled LWG-certified leather straps fastened by Velcro and finished with Tory Burch's signature hardware logo, it has an upscale aesthetic that's balanced nicely with ample comfort in the form of a cushy, molded leather footbed. Both the black-and-gold and white-and-silver colorways offer day-to-night wearability.

This casual shoe features a supremely comfortable OrthoLite footbed that is both breathable and moisture-wicking. The thick-strap, box-toe design is available in black or white calfskin leather or tan nubuck. It's made to last, and the brand offers a two-year guarantee against any manufacturing defects.

Learn about another pair of Camper shoes we love in our guide to the best loafers for women.

The chill gorpcore aesthetic of this sandal is accompanied by the Duckfeet brand's signature foot-shaped toe box, which is designed to allow your toes to comfortably splay. The shoes, available in nine colors, are built to last with leather that softens and molds to your foot with continued wear, and grippy Italian crepe rubber soles. Even better: the soles are biodegradable.

Direct-to-consumer brand Quince charges an average of 50-80% off traditional retail prices because it doesn't have to pay overhead costs. These reasonably priced 100% cow leather lug sole fisherman sandals are an excellent example of a wardrobe staple at a fraction of the expected price tag. The one-and-a-half-inch chunky platform has an EVA outsole for added cushioning.

Half-sandal, half-shoe, Miista's extra-chunky take on a fisherman sandal has a look that's both sporty and fashion-forward. It has a nearly two-inch lug sole platform. The thick leather straps, available in black or patent burgundy, are held in place by an adjustable looped elastic strap. For a more secure fit, the brand recommends tying a knot above the toggle to hold it in place.

J.Crew is known for its timeless designs and commitment to quality, and this sandal embodies the brand's signature blend of classic American style and modern sophistication. These leather sandals feature hand-braided, thin straps that offer both durability and artisanal flair. The T-bar leads to an adjustable ankle strap, while the cushioned footbed provides all-day wearability. These sandals pair effortlessly with casual denim shorts, flowy summer dresses, and everything in between.

This fresh spin on the fisherman sandal features an airy mesh design that feels both modern and effortless. The semi-transparent upper creates a barely-there aesthetic that's surprisingly supportive, making the half-inch-high sandal a smart pick for city strolls or casual weekends. A raffia version is also available and offers a beachy vibe.

The 1980s-classic jelly shoe might just be the most recognizable fisherman sandal of all. With this design, Boden offers an updated take on the nostalgic style with a vibrant two-tone palette. The rubber sandals are conveniently waterproof for summer adventures and give off a much cuter look than a typical watershoe.

Modern lines and a sustainable edge set this almond-toe Ref shoes apart. It's crafted from leather that softens beautifully over time and produced via a system with a carbon footprint 20% lower than conventional footwear, per the brand. The adjustable ankle strap ensures a secure fit, while the minimalist design pairs effortlessly with everything from linen dresses to tailored trousers.

This fisherman sandal-mule-hybrid shoe elevates any ensemble. With a square toe, a half-inch block heel, and thick straps that hug your foot, they're a beautiful yet comfortable choice for the office, casual daytime wear, or evenings out. The slip-ons run true to size.

Crafted in hand-finished leather and featuring a cushioned insole, this sandal is both chic and walkable — a rare combo for a 2.5-inch block heel. The cage-like upper, featuring a braid down the center, adds visual intrigue while providing a secure, breathable fit ideal for warm-weather wear. True to the brand's heritage, the Belmont is handmade in Brazil with a focus on quality and longevity.

With its minimalist sole and curved-strap silhouette, this pebbled leather fisherman sandal channels the edgy appeal of designer styles without the high-end price tag. The molded footbed and adjustable ankle strap provide comfort and support for all-day wear. Lightweight yet substantial, it's a great pick for everything from city strolls to casual brunches.

Priced affordably, this open-toe fisherman style offers a balance between style and functionality, ideal for those seeking reliable and fashionable footwear. Crafted from a mix of synthetic materials, including man-made leather, the sandal features a cushioned footbed and an adjustable ankle strap, ensuring a comfortable fit for extended wear.

While the materials may not be premium leather, many users find them suitable for casual outings and light activities. The sandal's minimalist design pairs well with various outfits, from casual jeans to sundresses.

If you're partial to a statement-making shoe, choose the cheetah-print, raffia, or lime green colorways of this fisherman sandal. They feature a leather upper, rubber sole, and buckle styling. Some users report the sole is a bit stiff, making them better suited for days with less strenuous activities. They run a touch small, so consider sizing up.