De La Salle baseball accused of sign stealing in formal complaint to NCS. Spartans adamantly deny allegations.
The NCS has confirmed it received the complaint from Dougherty Valley but says it hopes the schools resolve the matter on their own.
A baseball coach from a school in De La Salle’s league is accusing the Concord powerhouse of relaying catchers’ signs to batters, according to a formal complaint filed Friday to the North Coast Section office.
In the complaint, which was obtained by the Bay Area News Group, Dougherty Valley coach Kyle Stewart alleged that De La Salle has “personnel whom have devices such as cameras, telephoto lenses, walkie talkies, and verbal cadence from the coaching staff (that) creates a litany of questionable actions.”
De La Salle strongly denied the allegations.
The school’s athletic director, Leo Lopoz, wrote in a text message on Friday night that an internal investigation “found absolutely no evidence of sign stealing.”
NCS commissioner Pat Cruickshank confirmed that his office received the complaint and is hopeful that the schools can resolve the matter themselves.
“This is a complaint from one school to the other, and their two administrations can work on this together, and if I need to get involved I will,” Cruickshank told the Bay Area News Group on Friday. “I’d like to see if the two schools can handle things themselves, and if it’s unfounded, then it’s unfounded. If they agree on that, great. If not, we’ll take a look.”
Stewart declined to comment on the matter, and Dougherty Valley athletic director SueEllen Thomas did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Saturday.
The complaint alleges that during a game at Dougherty Valley on March 27, De La Salle coach David Jeans “repeatedly vacated the third base coaches area to peek over the foul line and into the catcher’s finger signals” before calling out “trust it” for a fastball or “battle” for an offspeed pitch.
The complaint states that Jeans stopped relaying signs when parents in the stands told him they were recording his actions.
During the next game between the teams, Tuesday at De La Salle, the complaint states that Jeans attempted to relay signs the same way for the first two innings.
“After the second inning, our pitcher, catcher, and staff completely changed our pitch calling signs,” the complaint claimed. “De La Salle had one hit for the remainder of the game.”
The complaint also alleges that a Dougherty Valley player noticed a man with a camera and large lens shooting from behind the center-field fence during Tuesday’s game.
“The same player allegedly heard a pitch called from that same area of (the) fence and immediately called time out and yelled, “This guy back here is calling pitches,” the complaint states. The man in question immediately packed up his stuff and scurried off.”
Jeans declined to comment when approached by a Bay Area News Group reporter after his team’s 7-3 victory at California on Friday.
Later Friday, Lopoz provided his statement, which read in full:
“On May 1, following a baseball game against Dougherty Valley High School on April 30, De La Salle was informed that some attending Dougherty Valley parents had made allegations that a photographer had been seen in the outfield and that this person had relayed game signs to De La Salle’s dugout during play.
“De La Salle immediately followed established protocols and conducted an internal investigation. This investigation found absolutely no evidence of sign stealing. Moreover, the photographer was identified as someone who attends and photographs high school baseball games and is well-known throughout the local area. He was at the game to take photographs for his personal use and to sell these images. He was not there at De La Salle’s direction or request.
“On May 3, De La Salle was copied on a letter that Dougherty Valley sent to North Coast Section (NCS), formally alleging sign stealing by De La Salle. In response, De La Salle immediately reached out to Dougherty Valley to refute the allegation and communicated the findings of its internal investigation with NCS and the East Bay Athletic League (EBAL).”
Neither NCS nor CIF addresses sign stealing in its bylaws. The practice is well documented throughout baseball history but is generally confined to the players and the field of play. When a team uses a scheme or technology to steal signs, that’s often viewed as breaking the bounds of sportsmanship.
Dougherty Valley won at home over De La Salle 6-5 on March 27, marking its first win in 15 games against its East Bay Athletic League rival.
Dougherty Valley lost at De La Salle 6-0 in Tuesday’s rematch.
Under Jeans, De La Salle has captured the past six North Coast Section Division I championships. The Spartans also won the first two Northern California Division I regional titles, beating St. Francis in 2022 and Valley Christian last season. The complaint was limited to games this season.
The victory over Valley Christian extended De La Salle’s postseason winning streak to 30 games. The program’s last playoff loss was to College Park in the 2015 NCS Division I final.
This season, De La Salle is 17-5 overall and 11-2 in EBAL play.
Dougherty Valley, in its first season under Stewart, is 7-16, 3-10. Since joining the EBAL in the 2016-17 school year, the Wildcats have not finished above .500 in league play.